Thursday, May 28, 2009

On Life Support

When a real estate deal is in trouble, or dying, the commercial brokers I use to buy & sell my buildings refer to it as, “On Life Support.” That was the status of my deal (see previous blog post) for probably two months before closing. Why? The buyer wanted to buy, the seller wanted to sell. They had agreed on price and terms, albeit grudgingly. Well it’s a long story, but the short answer is, the bank went bankrupt.

The buyer was selling another building, and making money on it. So he would have to pay capital gains. In order to avoid that, he structured the sale and subsequent purchase of my buildings as an IRC 1031 exchange. Properly executed, the proceeds of the sale are rolled into the purchase of the new property, and the IRS gets cheated out of their tax money. I believe this technique is widely know in real estate investment circles.

Because I had prepayment penalties on the loans underlying my buildings, and because I wasn’t getting a great price, part of the terms were that the buyer would assume my loans. The loans were assumable, and the interest was pretty good. The problem was that the buildings were selling for less than they had been appraised at when I refinanced. The bank insisted on cramming down the loans so that the LTV, Loan-To-Value ratio didn’t exceed 75%. The buyer was okay with that. It meant he had to come up with more cash, but cash wasn’t a problem for him due to his sale. The bank still insisted on a prepayment penalty on the crammed down portion of the loan. I’m not sure if the mortgage contract allows that or not, but they won. The pre-payment penalty was split three ways between the buyer, the seller (me) and the broker, making it palatable for all.

Somewhere in there the bank, Washington Mutual, went under and got bought out by JPMorganChase, which has swallowed so many banks in the last few years, it’s hard to fathom. It’ll be business as usual they insisted, but it wasn’t. Processing ground to a halt, I had verbal approval for the deal, one key signature and was waiting for the second key signature. I waited two months. The deal was supposed to close before Christmas 2008. Sometime in the beginning of February, the team working on the deal got laid off. The clock was ticking, and I had granted several extensions to the buyer, what else was I going to do? He wanted to close, and was ready, willing and able. In fact, he was willing to come to the table with all cash just to make things happen. A good buyer and honorable too! But I needed for the loans to be assumed, or half my profits would disappear in prepayment penalties.

My lawyer wrote a “Nasty-gram” to JPMorganChase threatening to sue them if they caused the deal to fail. They then resumed processing the loan assumption, and we closed on the very last day we could close and the buyer could still get his tax break. It was a great effort by the broker, and the lawyers for both the buyer and the seller.

I got lucky I guess. The buildings are most likely worth less now than what I got for them. They were in need of some upgrading and renovation, and I was getting a little tired after eight years. I also knew things were going to get worse for rental housing before they got better. The previous two years were tough, and mentally I wasn’t prepared to hang on. Also I had been (and still am) contemplating relocating to the Pacific Northwest, and would need to sell in order to do so. The buildings are no longer a barrier to my relocating. Also, after a little rest, I intend to start over, either as property manager working for a company, or independent again, but in nicer neighborhoods.

I’m not sure what the moral of the story is, or if there even is one. Life sucks, maybe? Or perseverance? Nothing ventured nothing gained? Never give up? It’s frustrating to me when things are out of my control and I’m trying to make something happen. Use good professionals, and hope for the best.

I Am An Ex-Landlord!

Well it’s been official for just about three months now. I managed to close the sale of my buildings as of the end of February, 2009. Is this a good thing? Yes and no. I feel a certain sense of lost identity, having been a landlord for 10 years. People used to call me “Carlton Sheets,” “Donald Trump” and “Slumlord.” It was a badge of honor. They used to screech with laughter, when after calling me a slumlord, I would correct them, informing them that I was “A professional property manager, focusing on the affordable housing sector.” There were times for sure that I felt like I was a slumlord. There were times that I hated my buildings, and when I visited, I just wanted to get away from them. It was amazing that so much of my net worth and identity was tied up in these properties.

There was a time when I was highly leveraged, and it freaked me out. I was making money hand over fist for about a six month period when I owned a total of four buildings with 48 units. But then the leverage got to me. So did the rough buildings. They have a saying on Wall Street, “If you can’t sleep, sell down to the sleeping point.” So I sold my buildings in Newark. I slept much better afterwards.

I feel like I got out just in time. I wish of course that I had sold when the market was higher. I knew when that was. I recently read on-line a comment from a laid off economist, “Just because you know a freight train is coming, doesn’t mean you can get out of it’s way.” I feel like that. Even though I had the sense that the market was near a top, I didn’t know what I would do if I sold. I thought I was a “Long Term Investor.” I thought the buildings would not only pay for my kids’ college education, I thought it would be the only way to do so. I still do.

My home is probably under water by $100,000. Not that I’m upside down on my mortgage, just that it’s worth that much less than I paid for it. I knew this was happening. So why didn’t I sell? I need a place for my family to live. Of course I could have sold and rented, but rental units are scarce and expensive in my town. I did talk about just renting when we bought this house, but ultimately I didn’t want to simultaneously be a landlord and a tenant. Financially it was the right move, but lifestyle-wise it was not. Also, even though I called a top in the real estate market, I didn’t call a freight train. As always, a crystal ball would have been helpful.

Tenant Rant 2

Tenant Rant 3

Late Rent

Thursday, July 17, 2008

Applicant Approval Reversal

I found this in the files, it is one year old...

Approval Reversal

I called the applicant above to let her know her application was approved. During the conversation, she asked me if I would install new closet doors in the apartment. I informed her the apartment is “As-is” and if she didn’t want it, she didn’t have to take it.

She told me she would have to “deduct money from the rent to fix the doors,” and that “she knows her rights as a tenant.” She argued with me for about 10 minutes.

In a conversation yesterday, she called to see if her application was received, and when she would know the result. I asked if she included all necessary documents, including picture ID. She hadn’t, and argued with me for about 10 minutes about how she had never had to do that before, etc. Based on these two arguments, I rescinded my offer to rent her an apartment.

Sunday, December 09, 2007

New Jersey's High-Rise Sprinkler Retrofit Proposal

Michael L. Ticktin, Esq.

Chief, Legislative Analysis

Department of Community Affairs

PO Box 802

Trenton, NJ 08625

RE: PRN 2007-297 – High Rise Suppression – Proposed Changes to N.J.A.C. 5:70-4.3, 4.7, 4.17

December 9, 2007

Dear Mr. Ticktin,

I am writing to express my opposition to the above captioned proposal. The negative effect that this proposed amendment will have on housing affordability in New Jersey – on the order of $200-$400 per unit – has been amply communicated to the DCA.

In exchange for a negative affordability effect, only negligible safety increases would be achieved. This proposal clearly runs counter to Governor Corzine’s stated goal of increasing affordable housing in the state.

I am deeply troubled by the fact that this proposal is being driven by the fire sprinkler installer’s union; clearly a self serving conflict of interest. The union members will profit off the backs of New Jersey’s honest landlords and hard-working, working class tenants.

In a testament to this proposal’s ill-considered nature, the strangest of bedfellows, the New Jersey Apartment Association and the New Jersey Tenants Organization, have joined forces to oppose this amendment.

New Jersey is already one of the most unaffordable states in America to live in, let’s not make it any worse. I respectfully request that the Department of Community Affairs not adopt the proposed amendments establishing the retrofit requirement.

Very truly yours,



Rosey